by Dr. Will — published on December 14th, 2007
Friday, Hartford, Connecticut
It took a global diplomat to do what baseball refused to do itself for over a decade. Retired United States Senator George Mitchell investigated and reported the cold facts about steroids and other, performance enhancing drugs rampant in the sport. His bombshell report released Thursday outed many major icons of the sport for cheating their way into glory. Pitcher Roger Clemens and Andy Pettitte were among the most high profile superstars to be named as steroid users.
The named athletes immediately denied the allegations and cried foul about the way their names were mentioned without due process. It certainly is a traumatic experience to have your public reputation sullied over night, given the widespread suspicion on all professional athletes. This surely is a case of being assumed guilty until you can prove your innocence.
However, my sympathies are not with the athletes. It was made clear by Senator Mitchell that everyone whose name emerged in the investigation was given an opportunity to speak with the investigators to clarify and clear their names in advance. And none of the accused players took advantage of the opportunity. This was foolish for two reasons:
First, Mitchell made clear that he was recommending that those named should not be penalized by baseball. This means that if the aggrieved individuals like Clemens had argued their case before the investigators, they might have had an opportunity to have their names be taken out of the report, even if temporarily until proof be found. By refusing, they suffered the consequences of the public relations bombshell.
Second, it ignored the widespread belief by most if not many fans that the players - especially those who accumulate staggering statistics late in their career - were not doing so honestly. What fan has not noticed the shocking change in Barry Bonds physical appearance? Who has not looked with curiosity - if not outright suspicion at the amazing stamina and pitching speed of Roger Clemens at forty years old? These are either super human accomplishments, or maybe the result of some help outside the rules.
The blame for this debacle most clearly rests principally with baseball as an institution and a business. And the irrational mania for sports that elevates the players to a divine status exacerbates the situation.
From the Commissioner’s office down to the owners of the teams appeared to ignore what seemed obvious to many, especially the sports journalists who were seeing these guys up close and personal. The change in appearance and attitude that was observed by watchers of the game raised suspicions decades ago. And most of the fans became curious during the infamous home run juggernaut when baseball’s legendary hitting records were suddenly overwhelmed by Sammy Sosa and Mark McGuire. It all seemed too easy.
What Do We Learn?
The baseball scandal is perhaps the inevitable result of a culture that so inflates the status of athletes and entertainers. Held up to a level of esteem that cannot be matched in reality distorts the fan’s perceptions as well as the self worth of the athletes themselves. When compensation bears little or no resemblance to the real value of the labor, it erodes self esteem. When a culture rewards people playing games, acting in movies and singing on stage by paying hundreds of times the remuneration as someone exhausting themselves through other forms of performance and service, it raises questions about all of our values.
I am not proposing that the local postal carrier, a truck driver or even my dentist be offered a salary of ten million dollars a year. But the labor of these individuals taxes their capacity as much as any other job. The staggering gap between their compensation and a baseball player is hard to comprehend.
There was a searing line in the movie Aviator when Leonardo DiCaprio, portraying the legendary engineer, inventor and industrial genius Howard Hughes chides Katharine Hepburn for criticizing him. He barks at her, “Don’t lecture me! You are just a movie star, that’s all!”
Uh huh!
Hughes had his sense of proportion right. I’m fine with celebrity athletes and entertainers being richly compensated for their work. But when we as a society lose all our sense of proportion, lionize them and exaggerate their real value, what should we expect but that they will cling tenaciously to their inflated status, even if it means cheating?