On the Couch: Uncomfortable But Loyal
Wednesday, Rochester, New York
Let me begin by asserting that I love living in Lafayette, Indiana. After a lifetime on the coasts, and missing many things about life in New York or Los Angeles, I am happily settled here. A major reason is that the revolution in technology has enabled me to remain connected to my national career interests right from here.
That said, I recall a local resident’s quip when I first arrived, Indiana, a great place to live but I wouldn’t want to visit here." I am sure that every place has its self effacing criticism that amuse the locals. All the years of my life that I lived in New York I knew a thousand jokes mocking the place. I thought of this these past few days while visiting Rochester, New York to speak to a great group of people with Lifetime Healthcare Companies. Life up there is no easy challenge.
Rochester, New York is set in the rural beauty of Western New York. It is set in the middle of a string of cities between Buffalo and Syracuse. Despite the physical appeal of the place, it has some of the worst weather imaginable. This area is routinely victimized by the famous “lake effect snow” phenomenon. Frigid cold fronts zooming down from Canada race across the Great Lakes picking up moisture and dump staggering amounts of snow here. It is a curiosity that so many choose to live here - that is - to remain here! In fact it would be interesting to now if they lose more of their children to relocation than other, more commodious places.
Nonetheless, the city is attractive and busy during the business day and it has all the expected features of a new city, from Starbucks to the Hyatt Hotel where I’m staying. So while a few million stout souls endure the bruising climate the question remains why? The most reasonable conclusion is that social connections, including family, friends and familiarity, usually trumps personal comfort. It’s why I live in Indiana instead of of New York or Los Angeles where opportunities for me abound. It’s why people stay in places like scorching Arizona, frigid Maine and steamy Houston.
It’s a reminder that, consciously or not, we are motivated to the familiar and uncomfortable with change - especially change that involves the loss of connections. Speaking about Refrigerator Rights and the problem of social isolation, the very place of the meeting was a reminder of the profound need that we have to connect and belong.
The intensity of the 2008 presidential election is a reminder to us of the stakes involved in this decision. And it also reminds us of why the modern classic television drama West Wing was so gripping. It satisfied the intense curiosity that ordinary citizens have about the most important individual in American society.
Any fan of West Wing comes to feel, accurately or not, that they have a sense of what the life is really like for our president. And what comes across clearly is that the stress of unexpected crises can be emotionally overwhelming for the president personally. It reinforces the need to have someone of a particularly solid emotional makeup to endure year after year of unexpected, and frequently dangerous eventualities. We have all observed how rapidly the President ages physically during their term in office.
I had a delightful interview with
As a person who has always been zealous about my career, the care-taking dimension of my marriage has occupied most of my attention. As for the cultivation matter, it has been a learning curve for me. I grew up in the processed food era, subsisting on canned vegetables and entrees that came frozen or in boxes. (To this day I must admit I sometimes indulge in Kraft macaroni and cheese). Essentially I had the taste palate of a goat.
These numbers are incomprehensible, but it is important that we do remember and reflect on the sacrifice that was made by that generation. The numbers alone validate their identity as “The Greatest Generation.” The numbers of lost and wounded was so staggering it meant that virtually every American family was touched by tragedy.
I find the approach of the administration and other national leaders to be nothing less than disgraceful. They have essentially told us to live our normal life, to be comfortable, while a few hundred thousand of the entire population fight for our freedom.
Among the news stories this week was the raid on the polygamist ranch in Texas. Over 400 children were taken from this religious compound, after allegations of “sexual abuse” were made against the adults in this community.
While many people find it shocking that a 16-year-old girl can be married and have children, the reality is that it wasn’t very long ago that boys and girls in their mid-teens were marrying and having children with the approval, consent and even encouragement of the society. These days of course, this sounds bizarre. Most parents have a hope and an expectation that their children at 16 will be engaged in the routines of high school, looking forward to several more years of education through college. Most parents would feel disappointed if their children opted out of late high school and college to get married and start their adult life as parents. But again, this was the norm not very many decades ago.
So what’s the right attitude here? Clearly the Texas situation is made more controversial because of this community’s practice of polygamy, a notion that is anathema in our society. But the children have been taken from these families not because of the polygamy, but because of the allegations that there were sexual relationships between adult men and adolescent girls. But if the “victims” in this community are above the age of 16 years old, then the issue of government intrusion becomes a lot more uncomfortable.
The news of the day is filled with stress producing events. Gas is four dollars a gallon, the war in Iraq has no end, the economy is tanking and health care costs are sinking families. The stress is getting unbearable. But where can people find relief? While many are helped by available medications, most just try to suck it up and endure the pressures of modern life.
Some experts see a hopeful possibility in the new technologies that could combine professional help with the attractive feature of privacy that comes with online interactions. In fact there has been an explosion of counseling and therapy services offered online. Internet therapy sites have sprung up over the past five years and now number near 400. The idea promises to help those too timid to seek help in person. There is little evidence so far about how effective online psychological treatment can be. The most significant concern is assuring the professional competence of the counselors who would be interacting with vulnerable people.
Some of the new recruits have been convicted of drug possession, assault and burglary. In some cases soldiers now serving have been convicted of actually making terrorist threats! Oh that’s just great!
Today may well prove to be a significant day in the presidential election. The Pennsylvania Democratic primary could determine whether Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama is the candidate to run against John McCain. While we celebrate that we have free elections, that our leaders are chosen by the people, most of us feel the frustration that what it takes to become president is often in the hands of a smaller group of power brokers.
Most of us wish that our electoral process was characterized by a little more democratic purity. The influence of media, powerful corporate forces and other mysterious power brokers makes many of us suspicious that we are not getting the best leadership available from among the populace.


