Weekend Reflection: Living Anywhere
Friday, New York City, New York
Coming to New York City to speak is always a delightful trip home. I was born in Brooklyn, raised on Long Island and have lived in Queens, Bergen County, New Jersey and finally in Manhattan. I have experienced just about every New York living experience. Now Sally and I live in Indiana and surely miss the City and its life. Part of us longs to return. But when I reflect on exactly what we miss it really comes down to a few discreet elements.
Anyone who has experienced life in a large city refers to the dynamism and energy that is felt all the time. New York is alive every hour of the day. We learned to sleep through the blare of fire engine sirens ten floors below that could wake the dead in Indiana. We enjoyed the dilemma of deciding which outstanding restaurant to select for dinner; there were dozens within two blocks of our home on 69th Street. As congested as the streets are, we were rarely affected since we used the subways and cabs available any time outside our door. We could get to a Broadway show ten minutes after leaving our building. It was all delightful.
If I concentrate on these things, the contrast to our life in Lafayette, Indiana simply pales. We have a scant selection of good, chef owned restaurants. Anything I need means driving and then within a limited number of hours for certain items. The energy is low and the pace is slow. It’s not New York, Chicago, Los Angeles of Miami. It’s not San Francisco, Boston or Philadelphia. It has little of what those great places have to offer, and there are certainly times we lament the choice.
However, a week in Los Angeles and New York City brings some other realities to mind. The energy on the street is muted, but in the quiet we sleep better. My house is not in walking distance to much, but it cost us less than a third of our homes in New York and so we travel a lot more. The rise of mega stores that has spread to virtually every town in America means that I really can get almost anything I need at anytime.
Yes, I do have to drive but there is virtually no traffic congestion. And as for the restaurants, that remains a disappointment. But we have both started to cook more at home and it has changed our social engagement with neighbors and friends.
In therapy we use the term “reframing” to encourage individuals to look at a challenging life situation from a different angle - to see opportunities where they are fixed on losses. As a native New Yorker moving to Indiana brought a lot of changes that I did not like. But when I reframed the situation I see the delightful quality of my present lifestyle and no longer miss daily life in New York, even as we enjoy periodic visits to walk around, shop and eat.
Oh yeah…and golf on a beautiful, Hale Irwin designed course is $40 with a cart on Saturday - no waiting.
No you are not insane (at least based on your letter). It sounds like you are being pushed to the side by someone bolder and more confident than you. Where is it written that you are the doormat? What does this other guy have that you don’t have. Before you answer, take stock.
1. Practice speaking louder. record yourself at different volumes and see which one affects your dog or cat, for instance. A booming voice makes others recoil!
1. While at home, watch the movie Patton and pretend you are a General in charge of all the others. Memorize his speeches and deliver them in front of a mirror in costume.
As each party inches closer to identifying their candidates, one of the main issues revolves around the experience of the candidates. And for the three left standing as of now, it would seem that Hillary Clinton and John McCain have significantly stronger credentials then the upstart Barack Obama. There is no question that Obama’s resume cannot compare to that of his rivals. But on reflection, I wonder what that really means?
In reality, it is the work of a President’s staff of the president to translate the ideas and commitments of the campaign into the administration’s policy and law. The president needs to be knowledgeable, of course, and articulate the policies of the nation to the world on our behalf. If this assessment of the office is valid, then it seems to me that the strategy taken by Clinton and McCain attacking Obama’s inexperience is not likely to stick. Their criticism that he is all rhetoric and little substance is not the slander that they think it is; it is not a criticism that has much weight. In fact, it might be that Obama’s capacity for elevated rhetoric, and inspiration is exactly what is most effective in that office.
Of course on the matter of experience, I am reminded of the worry that surrounded President John Kennedy, who also was a young, inspirational and charismatic figure. In David Halbertam’s Pulitzer Prize winning book, “The Best and the Brightest,” he detailed Kennedy’s early decisions upon his election to surround himself with the best minds he could possibly find from around the country. History will judge better than me, of course whether these great minds served him well or not. But at the time this instinct to surround himself with notable human resources went a long way toward reassuring people that he was up to the job.
Murder She Wrote was an enduring hit television classic that ran for twelve seasons (1984-1996). Veteran movie actress Angela Lansbury starred in the show, playing a widow, Jessica Fletcher who lives in a small, bucolic Maine town. She becomes a successful mystery writer in her retirement and soon an amateur detective. And in each episode she became entangled in yet another spectacular murder investigation. And in every case she is the one investigator who cracks the case, often against the instincts of the law enforcement professionals.
It begs the question, might not the first suspicion be on Ms. Fletcher herself as a serial killer?
1. Several of the commercials used inappropriate passion & misplaced melodrama to sell their product. For instance, what was GMC thinking using an illusion to the Myth of Sisyphus promoting their SUV? Huh?
Among the assignments that I give to the students in my class at Purdue, includes watching a documentary whose purpose is to persuade people. One of the obvious choices, of course, is Al Gore’s award winning “An Inconvenient Truth.” The film is quite a simple production really. It’s a recording of a Power Point presentation that Mr. Gore gives to an audience, making his case that the earth, in his words, “has a fever.” It is Exhibit A in the modern case that Global Warming is real and dangerous. His statistics are impressive; the case he makes is very persuasive. But of course we’re well aware that there are many skeptics who utterly reject his proposition that we are dead meat in a few decades.
Here in the Midwest our winter has than anything but warming. In fact, we’ve had six inches more snow for this month so far than is normal. It’s 7 degrees as I sit here. Making matters worse, there have been record-setting, devastating floods swamping dozens of communities throughout the Midwest. In our community, the city golf course still sits under several feet of water! And of course who knows what’s coming next?
The CBS drama Without A Trace continues to draw a large audience of viewers. What is behind the strong appeal of this program? Why are we enamored with stories of people who are lost and the endeavor of the F.B.I. to find them.
In the midst of such a dilemma we know deep down that we do in fact exist. But how can we be found? Sometimes we cannot make ourselves known; we must be found by someone else. And this must be someone else who cares about us. We need FBI agent Jack Malone.
Research has shown that Americans lead the developed world in stress related disorders. We have shocking rates of depression and anxiety, even when compared to other developed countries. In fact, a full 25% of Americans have a diagnosable, stress related psychological disorder. Here we are, leaders in the quality of our daily lifestyle, economic and military power, educational opportunity and yet we struggle with our mood. Hmm!
Of the two strategies for treating depression the science behind the medications is of course quite persuasive and reassuring. Less so is the efficacy of talk therapy. Many anxious or depressed people tend to dismiss the potential of psychotherapy because on its face it appears to be casual and with limited substance. 


